The 30-second rescue
"Order in the court! The Big Bad Wolf has been arrested. But there's a problem: he says the Three Little Pigs have been telling lies. Today, you are the jury."
Learning goals
- Distinguish fact, allegation and opinion.
- Evaluate conflicting evidence.
- Construct persuasive arguments.
- Practise formal speaking and listening.
The case
The prosecution alleges that the Wolf deliberately destroyed two houses and attempted to enter a third.
The defence claims the Wolf was suffering from an enormous sneeze and that the houses were badly constructed.
Witness statements
Pig One: "He said he'd blow my house down. Then he did."
Pig Two: "I heard a loud sneeze, but I also heard him shouting."
Pig Three: "My brick house stayed standing. He tried to get in through the chimney."
The Wolf: "I had a terrible cold. I only wanted to borrow some sugar."
The Builder: "I warned everyone that straw was not a suitable building material."
The activity
0 to 10 minutes: Introduce the allegations and assign roles.
10 to 20 minutes: Prosecution and defence prepare arguments and questions.
20 to 40 minutes: Conduct the trial. Question witnesses and present evidence.
40 to 50 minutes: Jury deliberates and announces a verdict.
50 to 60 minutes: Pupils write a short closing speech or newspaper report.
Key questions
- Which witness has direct knowledge of the events?
- Which statements are opinions?
- Is a badly built house evidence that the Wolf intended to destroy it?
- Can the jury reach a confident conclusion?
Make it work for everyone
Provide role cards and sentence starters. Allow non-speaking roles such as evidence organiser or court reporter. Extend by discussing reliability, bias and burden of proof.
Closing line
"The court is adjourned. The Wolf has been advised to buy tissues."