30-second opening
“We have a serious problem. Santa's sleigh has disappeared. The reindeer are ready, the map is ready, and Santa is walking around asking whether anyone's seen his keys. We need detectives.”
Goals
Infer from evidence; sequence events; write a justified conclusion; distinguish suspicion from proof.
Suspects
Elf mechanic, reindeer keeper, toy painter, snowman neighbour.
Five clues
1 Sleigh wheels had been squeaking. 2 A note says “Repairs scheduled for 4pm”. 3 The elf mechanic's workshop lights were on at 4:10. 4 The reindeer keeper says all reindeer remained in their stable. 5 A workshop log says “Sleigh collected for repairs at 4pm; return by 6pm”.
Pupil questions
Was it stolen? Evidence suggests no. Where is it? Repair workshop. Who moved it? Likely mechanic/workshop staff, but the log doesn't identify an individual. Which clue is strongest? 5. Why shouldn't we accuse the snowman? No evidence links them.
Run it
- 0 to 5 hook
- 5 to 15 clue reading
- 15 to 25 suspect/evidence table
- 25 to 35 detective report
- 35 to 42 reveal
- 42 to 45 reflection
Report frame
“At first I thought __. The strongest clue was __. I now believe __ because __. One question remains __.”
Support
Picture clues, shared reading, oral report. Stretch: Write an alternative misleading clue that is still fair; identify the limits of the evidence. Closing: “Case solved. Nobody stole the sleigh. Somebody simply forgot to check the workshop calendar. A very festive administrative disaster.”
Inclusive note
These are fictional seasonal lessons. Always offer a winter-themed alternative without assuming pupils celebrate Christmas, have presents at home, or enjoy holiday-related family discussions.