The 30-second rescue
"Three white powders have been found in the science department. They look almost identical. One is salt, one is sugar and one is chalk. Can you identify them from the evidence?"
Learning goals
- Interpret physical-property evidence.
- Compare solubility and electrical conductivity.
- Explain how observations can help identify substances.
- Distinguish evidence from assumptions.
Safety
This is a fictional, paper-based investigation. Pupils must not taste or handle unknown powders. Any practical testing requires separately approved school procedures.
The reference information
- Sodium chloride: soluble in water; its aqueous solution conducts electricity.
- Sucrose: soluble in water; its aqueous solution does not conduct electricity appreciably.
- Calcium carbonate: very poorly soluble in water.
Laboratory results
Sample A
- White crystalline solid
- Dissolves in water
- Solution conducts electricity
Sample B
- White crystalline solid
- Dissolves in water
- Solution does not conduct electricity appreciably
Sample C
- White powder
- Does not dissolve appreciably in water
The investigation
0 to 10 minutes: Introduce the mystery.
10 to 20 minutes: Review what solubility and conductivity tell us.
20 to 35 minutes: Teams identify each sample and justify their reasoning.
35 to 45 minutes: Challenge pupils to suggest why appearance alone is insufficient.
45 to 55 minutes: Design a safe sequence of tests using the provided reference information.
55 to 60 minutes: Present conclusions.
Teacher answer key
- Sample A: Sodium chloride
- Sample B: Sucrose
- Sample C: Calcium carbonate
These identifications assume the three samples are the stated substances and that the supplied laboratory observations are reliable.
Extension
Ask pupils what additional tests or controls they would need if the unknowns could include other substances.
Closing line
"Case solved. Three identical-looking powders, three very different sets of evidence."