30-second opening
“The coach says their training method always wins. Interesting claim. Today, we're not going to argue with them. We're going to collect evidence.”
Goals
Calculate success percentages; compare samples; identify fair-test issues; revise tactics.
Two safe options
Practical: 10 gentle throws/rolls towards a target, repeat after one chosen change (distance, stance or aiming routine), recording successes. Desk-based: use fictional data below.
Fictional results
Team A before coaching: 4 successes out of 10 (40%); after: 7/10 (70%). Team B before: 6/10 (60%); after: 6/10 (60%). Team C before: 3/10 (30%); after: 5/10 (50%).
Pupil questions
Which team improved most in percentage points? A, +30 percentage points. Did every team improve? No, B stayed the same. Does this prove coaching caused improvement? No; small sample sizes, practice effects and other changes could explain it.
Run it
- 0 to 8 introduce claim
- 8 to 18 baseline trials or dataset
- 18 to 30 adjust one factor
- 30 to 40 repeat/compare
- 40 to 50 calculate percentages
- 50 to 60 present evidence and limitations
Support
Fraction-to-percentage table and calculators; seated/desk-based route. Stretch: Compare improvement in percentage points versus relative percentage change; propose a larger fair trial. Safety: Check space and individual participation needs; avoid using reaction tests requiring contact or surprise stimuli.
Closing
“The coach might be right. The coach might be wrong. The brilliant thing is that now you know what evidence you'd need.”