The 30-second rescue
Deliver the announcement completely seriously.
"I've received an urgent message. Apparently, the headteacher has been taken aboard a spaceship. The aliens say they'll return them only if we can prove Earth is worth visiting."
Immediately clarify that this is a fictional writing challenge.
Learning goals
- Identify persuasive language.
- Select evidence to support an argument.
- Write for a specific audience.
- Adapt tone and vocabulary.
The alien message
"PEOPLE OF EARTH.
WE HAVE BORROWED YOUR HEADTEACHER.
YOUR PLANET APPEARS CONFUSING. YOU MAKE CHILDREN DO HOMEWORK, YOU EAT SOMETHING CALLED BRUSSELS SPROUTS, AND YOU HAVE INVENTED MONDAY MORNINGS.
CONVINCE US THAT EARTH IS WORTH VISITING.
YOU HAVE ONE LESSON.
COMMANDER ZOG."
The activity
0 to 10 minutes: Read the message aloud. Ask pupils to identify what the aliens misunderstand about Earth.
10 to 20 minutes: Collect arguments for Earth's best features: people, animals, music, food, sport, nature and inventions.
20 to 40 minutes: Pupils write a persuasive letter to Commander Zog.
40 to 50 minutes: Partners exchange letters and highlight persuasive techniques.
50 to 60 minutes: Volunteers read their strongest arguments. The class votes on the most convincing case.
Writing structure
Dear Commander Zog,
I am writing to explain why Earth deserves another chance.
Firstly...
Another reason...
You may be surprised to learn...
In conclusion...
Yours sincerely, Earth's Emergency Ambassador
KS1 adaptation
Write a short letter with three reasons, supported by drawings and sentence starters.
KS2 extension
Include rhetorical questions, emotive language, factual examples and a counterargument.
Closing twist
Reveal a second message:
"EARTH HAS BEEN APPROVED. YOUR HEADTEACHER IS ON THE WAY BACK. WE HAVE DECIDED TO KEEP THE BRUSSELS SPROUTS."
Teacher's trick
Ask one pupil to act as the alien ambassador and challenge weak arguments: "But why should we care about football?"